Print Page   |   Contact Us   |   Sign In   |   Join ASA or sign up
Sign In


Forgot your password?

Haven't registered yet?

Calendar

7/12/2015 » 7/31/2015
America and China: 150 Years of Aspirations and Encounters, Grand Rapids, MI

7/27/2015 » 7/30/2015
Wonders of Science, Alton Bay, NH

8/17/2015 » 8/21/2015
“The Origin and Concept of Life,” Galapagos Islands.

8/27/2015 » 8/29/2015
“Science and/or Religion: A 21st Century Debate,” Vienna, Austria

9/4/2015 » 9/5/2015
Patents on Life: Through the Lenses of Law, Religious Faith and Social Justice, Cambridge, England

a modern Jonah?
Moderator(s):
Thread Score:
Page 1 of 1
Thread Actions

3/15/2012 at 3:49:37 PM GMT
Posts: 6
a modern Jonah?
This topic has interested me for many years. Longtime ASA members may recall an article I wrote about modern Jonah stories: http://www.asa3.org/ASA/PSCF/1991/PSCF12-91Davis.html . I've never found any particular argument about the historicity of the biblical story very convincing, though I would not want entirely to rule it out.

The most interesting interpretation I encountered has already been stated in this thread: that Jonah, like Jesus, was actually dead for part of the time he was in the whale's belly. I didn't find that argument very often, but it was endorsed by at least a few commentators who wanted to push the parallel Jesus makes. The arguments against that possibility, given here, seem pretty good to me.


Last edited Thursday, March 15, 2012